Review: Stone Field by Christy Lenzi

2016, Reviews, Reviews by Morgan

Review: Stone Field by Christy LenziStone Field by Christy Lenzi
Published by Roaring Brook Press
Pub Date: March 29th 2016
Pages: 320
Format: eARC | Source: NetGalley
Genres: Historical, Young Adult
Buy the book! | Goodreads
3 Stars

In a small town on the brink of the Civil War, Catrina finds a man making strange patterns in her family’s sorghum crop. He’s mad with fever, naked, and strikingly beautiful. He has no memory of who he is or what he’s done before Catrina found him in Stone Field. But that doesn’t bother Catrina because she doesn’t like thinking about the things she’s done before either.

Catrina and Stonefield fall passionately, dangerously, in love. All they want is to live with each other, in harmony with the land and away from Cat’s protective brother, the new fanatical preacher, and the neighbors who are scandalized by their relationship. But Stonefield can’t escape the truth about who he is, and the conflict tearing apart the country demands that everyone take a side before the bloodbath reaches their doorstep.

Inspired by Emily Bronte’s Wuthering Heights, Stone Field is a passionate and atmospheric story of how violence and vengeance pervert the human spirit, and how hatred can be transcended by love. 

I’m so conflicted. On one hand this was everything I wanted the book to be, as far as a Wuthering Heights retelling set in the Civil War South. On the other hand, it was stranger than I imagined, and upsetting, and only about half of Wuthering Heights’ story.

I rarely review books less than 4 stars on the blog but I have a lot to say about Stone Field, and I do think it will be worth reading for a lot of people. It was for me. Though I will say point blank, if you did not like Wuthering Heights, or don’t think you’d like Wuthering Heights, you will NOT enjoy Stone Field. It follows the trajectory of WH in its makeup and tone, including some very passionate insta-love. I suppose in the original it was akin to insta-obsession since they were children when they first meet, and they are older teens here. It works for the characters and for the wildness of the story, but I know it will bother some readers.

I really enjoyed most of the book. I could see what the author wanted to do and reading her Author’s Note made me appreciate all the details of southern Missouri life that she included. I loved her use of language and the power of words. The tone was dark, fiery, and emotional. And she did a wonderful job of painting these very passionate, opinionated characters. I think Effie was my favorite character and I love her ambition to become a doctor.

Because of the nature of the time period, there are a lot of upsetting race related issues, as well as issues related to women. The way they are treated verbally and sometimes physically, the emotional trauma that they are put through.  But the issues are presented in a historically appropriate fashion, which in some ways made it so much harder to read. To imagine real people using such hurtful words and moreover having these hateful attitudes while truly believing they were right. It hurt my heart. And it’s not like these attitudes have disappeared today, either. The longer the book went on, the more difficult it got to read; I also didn’t care for the last quarter of the book, although the very end redeemed it a bit. It took an upsetting turn that I didn’t anticipate.

Cat is a witchy, strange, different sort of girl, which means she is misunderstood by just about everyone except her father and Stone Field. She’s dark and passionate, and loyal to herself. She had a unique view of the world but was very selfish and unlikeable at times, much like her inspiration Catherine Earnshaw. The book also dealt a lot with religion and trying to tame her wild ways through Christian kindness.  I loved the juxtaposition of Cat’s wild work, her vibrant response to nature vs the town’s increasing preoccupation with propriety and Christian evangelism.

Stone Field, the name that Cat gives the man she finds in their field, was an enigma for much of the book. We come to learn that he is a mix of Creek Indian and possibly African American; he slowly regains his memory and it’s just heartbreaking to learn the prejudices of every kind he’s endured. Even the “kind ones”; I don’t want to spoil because I think his journey is important to the story. I understood his need to find himself. His quest to uncover his past really brought out the selfishness of Cat’s character; she wanted him to forget it all and stay with her and embrace their love. That bothered me a lot, that she couldn’t see it from his perspective at all. That being said, I didn’t like how his story unfolded and wish it had gone differently. But I liked the glimpses of his sense of humor and his personality when he and Cat talk about Shakespeare and the constellations.

It was a beautifully written but flawed book with harsh characters and soul-consuming love vs duty. I’m glad I read it but I’m not sure I would read it again. I would recommend it to readers who love Wuthering Heights and readers who are intrigued by life during the Civil War.

 

 

About Christy Lenzi

Christy Lenzi

Christy Lenzi grew up in the hills and hollows of the Ozarks and now lives in California’s sunny Central Valley. When she’s not working, writing, or reading, she is fond of stuffing messages into bottles and throwing them into the river, making art, and zooming around on her motor scooter, Roxanne.

Top Ten Tuesday: Most Recent Five Star Reads
Stacking the Shelves

Morgan @ Gone with the Words

Morgan @ Gone with the Words

About Morgan @ Gone with the Words

Twitter | Goodreads | Instagram
Morgan lives in the Bay Area with her husband and her beagle. When she's not snuggling or taking care of Andy, she is reading, watching Disney movies, or drinking tea. Sometimes all at once! Her twitter tends to be bookish by day, sporty by night, and active all. the. time. Her TBR pile is out of control, as I'm sure you can sympathize. She is a big fan of caps locks, OMGs, movies, Chris Hemsworth, and anything British. Tweet her!

13 Responses to “Review: Stone Field by Christy Lenzi”

  1. Jessie

    Oh, man I am sorry this wasn’t a better fit for you — I remember chatting on twitter about it. How weird that it only covers some of Wuthering Heights when it’s being labelled a retelling. I mean, I guess that’s one way to make your version stand out? ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

    On the other hand, I love when the author’s note is just as fascinating as the book. That happens a lot with hist fic and I think it really adds to the whole book’s feel.

    I wasn’t interested in this (you know why) but I have to admit this line ” I loved the juxtaposition of Cat’s wild work, her vibrant response to nature vs the town’s increasing preoccupation with propriety and Christian evangelism” makes me more interested than anything else I have seen about the book.

    Great review, Morgan!

    Jessie recently posted: Review: The Guardian by Jack Whyte
    • Morgan @ Gone with the Words

      I am too; I loved it at first and then it went off the rails. Ironically MOST Wuthering Heights media (besides the actual book) only covers half the story! There’s sort of a natural reasons/splitting point but I still find it strange.

      The author’s note was wonderful, I completely agree about it adding to the book’s feel!

      Awww you are sweet! Reading that line back makes it sound like I was writing a thesis statement or something haha :D Thank you for commenting!!

  2. Andrea

    You have me intrigued with your review of this book. I absolutely loved Wuthering Heights (I know it’s kind of weird) but I’m untrustworthy of someone actually doing a retelling of this book, it’s a difficult one to do for sure. I’m sorry that it didn’t fully work out for you, but that you still somewhat enjoyed the journey with this book. I’m definitely going to have to put it on my list to give it a try. Thanks for the review :)

    • Morgan @ Gone with the Words

      I love Wuthering Heights too!! I always feel like I’m in the minority haha. It’s interesting because it works really well in a lot of ways, you can see the bones of WH in the story, but it didn’t quite get there for me. I’d be interested to hear what you think if you read it! Thanks for commenting :)

  3. [email protected] Friends Are Fiction

    I have never read Wuthering Heights! I’ve always intended to but never have. I know the gist and I’m okay with going into this expecting something similar…like the insta love. I’m glad I’m warned! I really hope this one works for me. We’ll see since it’s up this month for me to read. Wonderful review!

    [email protected] Friends Are Fiction recently posted: Stacking the Shelves
    • Morgan @ Gone with the Words

      I read it in high school and loved it, although I am definitely in the minority haha! Okay good, I mostly worried about that because I know people have such strong feelings on instalove (I do too) but it’s very in the spirit of the original. I hope you like it, let me know what you think :)

Leave a Reply

Want to include a link to one of your blog posts below your comment? Enter your URL in the website field, then click the button below to get started.